Warm restaurant windows in a historic brick downtown storefront, with a small sidewalk cafe table on a quiet late-autumn afternoon.

What's Coming to the Old Tavern Littleton Building on Main Street

The two-story building at Main and Curtice was built in 2011. It has sat empty since February 2024. That's nearly three winters of a dark storefront in the middle of Downtown Littleton. The restaurant planned for 2589 W. Main St. is Chachi's Italian-American, a steakhouse with handmade pasta. It's targeting a February 2027 opening, and the people behind it already run Grande Station farther east on Main Street.

Main Street's newest big project comes from the same people who were already working downtown, and most of the recent food and drink changes around downtown have followed that pattern.

Nearly Three Years Dark at Main and Curtice

The Tavern in Littleton was one of seven Tavern locations around the Denver metro run by Tavern Hospitality Group. All seven have now closed. In February 2024, BusinessDen reported that the group was closing its last locations and selling properties as its founders parted ways. Littleton's was among the final two to close.

The building went up for sale soon after and changed hands slowly. City staff wrote that it went under contract several times before Main Street Partners 1 LLC bought it in January 2026. In a November 2026 council memo, staff called 2589 W. Main "a notable vacancy along Main Street." They also wrote that "regular visitors, community members, and business owners have voiced the desire to see this space filled." The same memo says the building will need extensive repair work before anyone can serve a meal in it.

If you walk Main Street often, you know where the building sits. Grande Station is at 2299 W. Main to the east, and The Melting Pot is at 2707 W. Main to the west. A lit, busy restaurant at Main and Curtice would fill the empty stretch between those two.

The Couple Who Already Run Grande Station

Rachel and Eric Hyatt own and operate Grande Station, on the corner of Main and Sycamore. WhatNow Denver describes Grande Station's menu as scratch-made cooking that draws on several cuisines, with an emphasis on local ingredients. According to the city's memo, revenue rose 58% in the Hyatts' first full year of owning the restaurant. The memo also notes that the couple have spent the past three years active in Littleton's business community.

Chachi's is a different kind of restaurant from Grande Station. Rachel Hyatt described it at Littleton's State of the City event as a fine-dining steakhouse with Italian-American influences, including handmade pasta. WhatNow Denver reported that the goal is a polished dinner that doesn't feel overly formal. City staff described it as a small business meant to fill the gap between traditional Italian-American dining and the contemporary American steakhouse. Chachi's has its own site at chachislittleton.com.

The last restaurant in the building, the Tavern, was an American sports bar. If Chachi's opens as planned, the corner will host a dressier dinner than it did before it closed.

What the Building Is Set to Become

According to the city's Nov. 10 council materials, Chachi's plans to use about 6,140 square feet of the building. The plan calls for roughly 235 seats, with room for more upstairs. The second floor will hold more dining and flexible space for private events. Planned interior work includes a new entrance and storefront, rooftop terraces, new finishes and hardwood floors.

Rooftop terraces would give Main Street more outdoor seating above street level, and a second floor for private events adds another option for rehearsal dinners, work parties and family gatherings in the historic district.

BusinessDen put the total investment at $2.8 million, with an opening planned for February. WhatNow Denver's Nov. 11 report puts that target at February 2027.

The City's Part in the Project

The Hyatts asked the City of Littleton to share back part of the sales tax the restaurant will collect. In a document quoted by BusinessDen, the city said "current economic conditions have impacted original estimated costs as much as 30%." Under the terms staff proposed, the city would rebate 50% of the restaurant's sales tax. The rebate would end once it reached $350,000 or after five years, whichever came first. The city would keep all use tax and property tax. Staff projected that the restaurant would generate about $179,000 in sales tax in year one and about $208,000 in year five. That's roughly $1 million over the five-year term, before any rebate is paid.

Council discussed the request at a Nov. 10 study session. The agreement, Resolution 82-2026, went on the agenda for a formal vote on Nov. 17. The resolution, the financial agreement and both presentations are attached to the Nov. 17 council agenda. This isn't the first downtown project where the city has played a role. Our earlier post covered the city's role at Santa Fe and Mineral.

Downtown's Other Recent Changes Came From People Already There

The Chachi's plan matches what has happened elsewhere downtown over the past year or so. Most of the recent changes came from businesses that were already there.

DIRT Coffee moved from its old spot on Rapp Street to 2506 W. Alamo Ave. and opened there on Oct. 17, 2025. According to the Littleton Downtown Development Authority, the larger space added a workforce-development center to the coffee shop.

The Melting Pot at 2707 W. Main St. reached 30 years in 2026. It opened April 15, 1996. The Littleton Independent reported that Tony Wheeler started there as a server in 2006 and became the owner in 2021. Like Chachi's, it's a downtown restaurant now run by someone who already worked on Main Street.

A few other places have joined the downtown mix. Tonic Zero Proof Bar at 5767 S. Rapp St. makes alcohol-free cocktails and specialty drinks. The DDA profiled it in August 2026 and described its daily hours and events. Hearth opened a bakery and coffee shop at 5610 S. Curtice St. in 2025. Curtice is the same street that meets Main at the old Tavern corner. Visit Littleton included Hearth in its 2026 roundup of what's new in town.

Every place in this section is a short walk from Main and Curtice. Chachi's would join a stretch where the coffee shop grew by moving across downtown and the 30-year fondue restaurant is owned by its former server.

Main Street Between Now and February

The planned work at 2589 W. Main includes a new entrance and storefront, so the corner's look will change before the opening. In the meantime, the Hyatts' cooking is already on Main Street at Grande Station, 2299 W. Main, on the Sycamore corner. The Melting Pot sits a short walk west of the Tavern building for a holiday dinner, and DIRT Coffee at 2506 W. Alamo Ave. works for a morning stop. For a longer walk around downtown and the river, our earlier post on everyday life from Main Street to the river covers the area.

A two-story building with rooftop terraces and a private-event floor is the kind of renovation Lynn Marie Baxter loves watching up close, and she'll be following Chachi's progress at Main and Curtice through the winter. If you live near downtown and wonder how a busier Main Street affects what your own home is worth, request a free home valuation from Lynn Marie.

Work With Lynn Marie

With a background in remodeling, including kitchen and bath design, and property investment, I bring a detail-driven approach to every real estate experience. I take the time to understand your goals, offering thoughtful guidance and strategic insight from start to finish. Whether you’re buying, selling, or investing, I’m committed to delivering a smooth, well-managed process and results you feel confident referring to friends and family.

Follow Me on Instagram